Modern headlines, historical answers

Echoes

Today's headlines, each paired with a moment from the past that rhymes with it: what happened then, why, how it was resolved, and how it turned out.

“Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”
— George Santayana, The Life of Reason (1905)

Story

November 2, 2026
Politics

America votes Tuesday with control of Congress at stake

Monday is the last day of campaigning before Tuesday's U.S. midterm elections, which will decide all 435 House seats and 35 of the 100 Senate seats. Republicans hold slim majorities in both chambers, and Democrats are trying to flip enough seats to win control. More than 54 million Americans had already voted early, according to the University of Florida Voting Lab. Read at BBC News →

The echoAncient

Rome adopts the secret ballot

Roman Republic, 139–107 BC

What happened then

In 139 BC the tribune Aulus Gabinius passed a law requiring Roman citizens to vote for magistrates by written ballot instead of calling out their choice aloud. Voters marked a small wax tablet and dropped it into a basket. Further laws extended the secret ballot to criminal trials in 137 BC, to votes on legislation in 131 BC, and finally to treason trials in 107 BC.

What caused it

Roman politics ran on patronage. When votes were spoken aloud, powerful men and their agents could see exactly how their clients, tenants and dependents voted, and lean on them. Reformers saw a written, private ballot as a way to free ordinary voters from that pressure.

How it was resolved

The aristocracy resisted, but the ballot laws stuck. Cicero's dialogue On the Laws records the argument decades later: his brother Quintus attacks the ballot for stripping the leading men of their influence, while Cicero suggests a compromise that keeps the ballot but lets voters show it to respected citizens if they choose.

How it turned out

The secret ballot did not end corruption. Bribery of voters remained a constant scandal, and Rome passed law after law against it. But the principle that a citizen's vote is his own outlived the Republic, and it returned in modern democracies, where the 'Australian ballot' spread across the United States in the 1880s and 1890s.

Sources: Wikipedia: Ballot laws of the Roman Republic · Cicero, On the Laws III (tr. Barham, ToposText) · Wikipedia: Secret ballot

Further reading: SPQR by Mary Beard